rate_review Reviews

This plot is absolutely wonderful. I love it. It feels like your creativity is never going to cease. Please bless me with your update soon!

This story is pretty intersting so far. I like your Erestor. I can't decide whether you should kill Morcorban or not though. I suppose it would be nice to see him live. I had kinda figured he would die though, so I didn't put too much thought into him as more than just the bad guy. I always hate it when characters I like die. Hmmm... I suppose I'd like him more if he lived. I vote: let him live.

Sorry I have not left feedback here before, but I was following this one on the lists. I must say it is full of surprises at every turn. Erestor attacking Glorfindel, Lindir turning traitor, and Morcorban...the Elf I absolutely hated at the beginning...turning the tables and supplying Elrond the formula for Erestor's antidote. Now that I know the reason behind his madness, I am PRAYING that he will make it through the story alive! I know Melkor is a Ell Elladan, but the new twist...Celebrian and Arwen will be interesting. To use my favorite line...Look forward to your next update!

Mirasaui

OOH! I simply must know what happens, must. Must. Must must must. This is such an interesting story!

Great story! Just read the first chapter, love it so far! The blond elf wasn't Legolas,was it? I hope it wasn't. I pray it wasn't. Poor Erestor.

So cute...Adorable in fact. Shame it's only fake memories. Hopefully I'm following this correctly. Just a bit confused. Poor, poor, poor Erestor.

This story is getting more and more interesting with each chapter. Keep it going, I will like to see how this one ends.

So glad this fic is back; hope Lindir's deceit is exposed and that Morcorban makes it to Imladris and finds a way to save Erestor; look forward to more:-)

O my.I am getting sooooooooo curious.Pleaseeeeeeee more.Feed me.Mwhahaha just kidding.Like it still.

Hi,

Hmm.. Melkor is not really free, is he? Methinks the dark elf works for him, for freeing Morgoth...
Eresis sis suffering - poor elf.. /me huggs him better.
And who was the darkelf reffering to? Gilgalad? Sauron? Or somebody else?

Please more, I need this story!

Bye,
-Kira-